Correct the post-shrub 368 stride: real, but in one 15 KB window
The claim that the post-shrub region has a 368-byte period throughout is wrong. Re-measured over the whole region the curve is flat and near noise: stride 8 +0.027 stride 12 +0.023 stride 148 +0.009 stride 340 +0.018 stride 368 +0.018 stride 632 +0.020 Nothing peaks at 368, and the 0.1110 recorded earlier does not reproduce under any sampling convention tried. Where the structure is: scanning 8 KB windows at 1 KB steps for a 368-excess above 0.15 finds one substantial region, region+41984..+57344, 15360 bytes, plus a 4 KB patch at region+650240. Within that window 368 is unambiguous -- +0.315 against +0.284 at 736, with 364, 372 and 732 all at noise. 41 whole records, mean 16 distinct values per position, and nine positions exactly constant and zero: 329-336 and 340. Twenty-five positions have 3 or fewer distinct values, clustered in 325-349, which is a tail rather than scattered padding. Corrected statement: a 15360-byte window of the post-shrub region is a table of 41 records at stride 368, each with a roughly 43-byte tail whose fields are mostly zero. The surrounding 675 KB is not that table. What went wrong before: the original measurement was taken over a window where 368 held, then reported as a property of the region. That window holds 41 of 1841 records, and averaging it over the region flattens the peak to the noise floor. The re-verification checked the stride but not whether it applied uniformly, so it confirmed the number without testing the claim attached to it.
This commit is contained in:
@@ -670,3 +670,58 @@ multiples confirm it), and the alignment with four constant zero positions is
|
||||
solid. What sits in those bytes is not a record layout, and the two findings
|
||||
are in tension in a way this project has not otherwise seen: a confirmed
|
||||
period that is not a record boundary.
|
||||
|
||||
## Correction: the 368 stride is real, but confined to one ~15 KB window
|
||||
|
||||
The claim earlier in this file that the post-shrub region has a 368-byte
|
||||
period *throughout* is wrong. Re-measured over the whole region, the
|
||||
autocorrelation curve is flat and near noise:
|
||||
|
||||
| stride | excess over matched shuffled control |
|
||||
|---|---|
|
||||
| 8 | +0.027 |
|
||||
| 12 | +0.023 |
|
||||
| 148 | +0.009 |
|
||||
| 340 | +0.018 |
|
||||
| **368** | **+0.018** |
|
||||
| 632 | +0.020 |
|
||||
|
||||
Nothing peaks at 368. The figure of 0.1110 recorded earlier does not
|
||||
reproduce under any sampling convention tried (step 1, 2 or 4 through the
|
||||
window; all give ~0.018).
|
||||
|
||||
**Where the structure actually is.** Scanning 8 KB windows at 1 KB steps for
|
||||
a 368-excess above 0.15 finds exactly one substantial region:
|
||||
|
||||
region+41984 .. region+57344 = 15,360 bytes (abs 16089024..16104384)
|
||||
|
||||
plus a 4 KB patch at region+650240. Everything between and around is flat.
|
||||
|
||||
**Within that window the 368 stride is unambiguous:**
|
||||
|
||||
| stride | excess |
|
||||
|---|---|
|
||||
| **368** | **+0.315** |
|
||||
| 736 | +0.284 |
|
||||
| 364 | +0.024 |
|
||||
| 372 | +0.021 |
|
||||
| 732 | +0.027 |
|
||||
|
||||
The peak is sharp, 736 confirms it as a multiple, and the neighbours are at
|
||||
noise.
|
||||
|
||||
**Record shape.** 41 whole 368-byte records. Mean distinct values per
|
||||
position is 16 of 41, and **nine positions are exactly constant and zero**:
|
||||
329 through 336, and 340. Twenty-five positions have 3 or fewer distinct
|
||||
values, clustered in 325-349 -- a tail region rather than scattered padding.
|
||||
|
||||
So the corrected statement is: a 15,360-byte window of the post-shrub region
|
||||
is a table of 41 records at stride 368, each with a roughly 43-byte tail
|
||||
whose fields are mostly zero. The surrounding 675 KB is not that table.
|
||||
|
||||
**What went wrong before.** The original measurement was taken over a window
|
||||
where 368 held and then reported as a property of the region. The 15 KB
|
||||
window holds 41/1841 of the region's records, and averaging that over the
|
||||
whole region flattens the peak to the noise floor. The re-verification pass
|
||||
checked the stride but not whether it applied uniformly, so it confirmed the
|
||||
number without testing the claim it was attached to.
|
||||
|
||||
Reference in New Issue
Block a user